Prana Brion II Pants Review
Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
This Product
Prana Brion II Pants | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Awards | |||||
Price | $84.99 at Amazon Compare at 2 sellers | $98.95 at Amazon Compare at 2 sellers | $99 List $99.00 at REI | $80 List $55.93 at REI | $65 List $47.98 at Amazon |
Overall Score | |||||
Star Rating | |||||
Bottom Line | The simplest hiking pant that also proved to be the most stylish for everyday wear | For comfort and breathability, these pants can’t be beat | This stellar pant surprised us with its high performance at an affordable price | These pants offer mobility without skimping on features | These pants are lightweight, but offer limited mobility and therefore limited versatility |
Rating Categories | Prana Brion II Pants | Outdoor Research Fe... | Patagonia Quandary... | REI Co-op Sahara Co... | Columbia Silver Rid... |
Comfort and Mobility (35%) | |||||
Venting and Breathability (20%) | |||||
Weather Resistance (15%) | |||||
Features (15%) | |||||
Versatility (15%) | |||||
Specs | Prana Brion II Pants | Outdoor Research Fe... | Patagonia Quandary... | REI Co-op Sahara Co... | Columbia Silver Rid... |
Weight | 10.7 oz | 12.2 oz | 9.7 oz | 11.9 oz | 10.4 oz |
Material | 95% recycled nylon, 5% spandex | 86% nylon, 14% spandex; 90D stretch woven ripstop | 94% nylon (62% recycled), 6% spandex | 96% recycled nylon, 4% spandex | 100% nylon Silver Ridge ripstop |
Water Resistance | DWR finish | DWR finish | DWR finish | DWR finish | No additional treatment |
Sizing (Waist, Length Options) | W: 28" - 42" L: 28" - 36" |
W: 28" - 42" L: 30"- 36" |
W: 28" - 40" L: 30", 32", 34" |
W: 28"- 50" L: 28" - 34" |
W: 28"- 44" L: 28" - 36" |
Sun Protection | UPF 50 | UPF 50 | UPF 40+ | UPF 50 | UPF 50 |
Pants/Shorts Convertibility | No | No (but have ankle cinch cord and fully convertible version available) | No | Yes | Yes |
Pockets | 2 hand, 2 back, 1 coin | 2 hand, 2 back, 1 thigh zip | 2 hand, 2 back (1 zip), 1 thigh zip, 1 coin | 2 hand, 2 back velcro, 2 thigh (1 zip, 1 flap) | 2 hand, 2 back velcro, 2 thigh (1 zip, 1 velcro) |
Waist Strap and Fastener | Button and zip fly | Button and zip fly | Button and zip fly, integrated elastic cord | Button and zip fly, elastic across back | Button and zip fly, full belt, elastic on hips |
Other Features | Gusseted crotch, belt loops, mesh pockets | Drawcord cuff closures, side zip pocket | Front and back knee articulation, gusseted crotch, slim straight fit | Removable legs with color-coded zippers and vertical zippers, elastic in waist | Gusseted crotch, full belt, elastic waist |
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Brion II is very functional as a hiking pant but also excels as a casual, everyday pair. The stretch fabric ensures that they are super comfortable against the skin, while also offering superior mobility, durability, and protection you would expect from an outdoor pant. This model has a relatively slim and straight cut. They come in a wide variety of earthy colors, ensuring that you will look as comfortable in a meeting at work as out on the trail.
Performance Comparison
Comfort and Mobility
The Brion II is a very comfortable pant that ranks up there with our favorite pairs in this metric. In particular, we love the 95%/5% nylon/elastane blend that offers just the right amount of stretch in the crotch and upper legs. The fabric feels soft against the skin, and we appreciate that even though they are cut a little slim, mobility is rarely limited. We like the gusseted crotch. The fly zipper could stand to extend a bit lower but it's totally functional.
The front secures with a button closure. We appreciate that it is relatively low profile, which makes it more comfortable underneath a backpack hip belt or a climbing harness. Though it doesn't have a felted waist we didn't experience any hip abrasions while hiking. These pants also retain their stretch, that is, they can be worn many, many times between washes before the waist starts to get noticeably looser.
Venting and Breathability
During our hiking field tests, we noticed that these pants hold more heat compared to the competition. The stretch fabric is a bit heavier than the material found on the most breathable pants. Weighing in at 12 ounces, the pair is about average for the category, however, the slimmer fit suggests there is also likely less material through the legs and there are few other features to add weight, so we suspect that the fabric itself is heavier than most pants. In addition, the Brion II has very few ventilation features. It comes with mesh-lined front hand pockets. However, considering the openings for these pockets lay flat against the leg, it's not a significant feature for releasing heat.
There are no crotch holes or roll-up cuff snaps. However, we did notice that the gusset is a slightly lighter material than the rest of the pants. Even with this subtle addition, they are not our favorite choice for hot weather. Having said that, because of the slimmer fit, the legs do roll up securely if you need some relief on a warmer day.
Weather Resistance
Though these pants come with a durable water-repellent (DWR) coating applied to the outside, we found that water soaks in much more quickly than most hiking pants we tested. In a light mist, water droplets bead up and run off, but in a true rainstorm, these pants rapidly become saturated. Not only that, but they also start to feel wet on the inside against the skin almost immediately. If you need a pant that has solid water repellency, we recommend looking elsewhere.
However, when it comes to wind resistance, this model is a little bit sturdier. The mid-weight fabric insulates better than its airier counterparts. In addition, these pants dry comparatively quickly. Despite their underperformance in wet weather, they are durable. Their simple design means that there are no small plastic parts to fall off or break. Riveted pockets and a reinforced waist also add to their durability.
Features
The Brion takes a minimalist approach to features. In fact, there is nothing extra at all. There are two front handwarmer pockets (with an inset coin pocket on the right side), two rear pockets, and belt loops, and that's it. The front pockets aren't especially deep, and we never felt totally comfortable stashing anything essential like car keys in them while out on the trail. Having said that, they are totally serviceable throughout the day to day. The same goes for the rear pockets; they are proportional to the overall slender style of the pants.
There are no extra cargo pockets, drawcords, zip-off bottoms, or any of the features found on most comparable hiking pants. It is worth mentioning, though, that these pants have a UPF 50+ rating, meaning their ability to shield you from the sun has been lab-tested and confirmed. They are also manufactured with recycled nylon, and the fabric is Bluesign-approved. We actually rather enjoy their simplicity; it's just important to know what you are getting with this model.
Versatility
These pants lack the technical features that would expand their versatility across a wider array of activities and seasons. As discussed above, they have thicker fabric, are not convertible, and don't have any substantial ventilation points to help cool you off, like roll-up cuff cinch cords or snaps. All of this diminishes their versatility for hot weather or long backpacking trips.
On the other hand, they are still quite functional for outdoor work around the house, for traveling, and for car camping. On top of that, they look great. Their stretch makes them a good option for hiking, but these pants are easily passable as officewear in many settings. They come with traditional belt loops, so it is simple enough to make them look even nicer (as opposed to many hiking pants that come with an integrated outdoor-looking belt). In fact, these pants are more notable for their fashion-forward aesthetic than their technical expertise.
Should you Buy the Prana Brion II?
The Prana Brion II look, feel, and perform far closer to an average pair of casual pants than they do to a technical piece of outerwear. We think this model provides plenty of good value for the right wearer. Though they are super simple and lack all of the technical features of typical hiking pants, we have to admit that we love this pair for its style and cross-functionality between trail and town.
What Other Hiking Pants Should You Consider?
For those who just need more features, the Outdoor Research Ferrosi is also a simple model but comes with an additional leg pocket and internal drawstring. If style is what you are after, the Royal Robbins Alpine Road is another office-ready pair. If you like the simplicity of these pants but prefer a techy aesthetic, the Arc'teryx Gamma is a good pair to look at as well. Lastly, in the other direction, if you like the Prana brand, don't care about frontcountry style, and want highly functional pants, the Prana Stretch Zion II is a sure bet.